P.S. I still welcome your thoughts on my post on Experience below.
Apparently, there was a sale on silver ties in St. Paul. Many of the male anchors seem to be wearing them.
My quick take: He got WAY off early on. He seemed uncomfortable with the prompter, the protesters were distracting and the first part was a little, well, eh. The middle was so-so. I think the text was good in the middle, bu the delivery was poor, frankly. But then, he came alive. There was a good message, a good cadence, good crowd reaction. It was very impressive. The call to service and the call to action was both impressive and inspiring. I have NO idea how this will play. At the end of the day, however, McCain was McCain. He’s not an orator. He’s a hero, he’s a statesman, and he’s his own man. He took the party to task in some places - and mostly in the right places. Now, if he wants to take this to victory, he’s got to hit the road and do his town halls and roundtables and win over voters one by one. Let’s hope he keeps with the good conservative message, though. And uses Sarah Palin often. Your thoughts?
11:18 p.m. - I’ve just learned from CNN that John McCain likes confetti “more than anything else.” I kind of doubt that, but okay…
I’ll be honest. I really love these balloons. Republicans do this so much better than Democrats!
MSNBC: Chris Matthews just predicted a big bump for McCain. “Americans want to support a winner.” Interesting…
Nice shot of all the Fox anchors turned around looking at the balloons. You gotta love them.
I like the fireworks - does it beg comparisons between this and the ACTUAL fireworks at the DNC?
Oh, thank goodness. Here come the balloons.
COME ON - BALLOONS! Are we going to have a 2004 DNC moment?
Where are the balloons? And the families? Make the celebration happen!
Excellent ending. If only he’d done that throughout the speech. But, excellent end. I have goosebumps, even though I wasn’t terribly impressed with the rest of it.
“Fight with me. Fight for what’s right for our country.” GOOD - KEEP TALKING! This cadence is great!
11:00 p.m. “I wasn’t my own man anymore. I was my country’s.” (P.S. My wife says he sounds like Casey Kasem.)
Hey, we’ve got some crying folks, too!! Not just the provence of “The One.”
I do wish he’d do better about talking through the applause - only stopping at the right times.
Nice visual with the servicemen giving the standing ovation.
He seems very comfortable now. The cadence is better, his voice is better, his eyes are better connecting. He does seem more grown up than Senator Obama, no question about that.
“I hate war.” Good.
This should be the best part of the speech. This is where Senator McCain shines.
I don’t think I heard Cap and Trade mentioned. That’s good, I guess!
DRILL DRILL DRILL
10:43 p.m. “Help bad teachers find another line of work.” I LOVE IT. That may be the line of the night so far. Smack around the NEA some more!
Woo hoo - shout out for school choice! Preach on.
He needs to do this “I will…He will” section with a bit more umph. Sadly, it’s clear there’s a big gap between the oratory skills of Palin and McCain. But, the substance is pretty good.
10:38 p.m. I like this “we believe” section. Define the Republican party. This is a section that’ll both rile the crowd but also define the broader priciples for the viewing audience. Good. I wonder how many people are watching?
“The Party of Lincoln, Roosevelt and Reagan is going to get back to basics!” Good!
We’ve got a little economic populism going here. Not that I always agree with it, but I think, at this point and time, it’s effective.
Good, now we’re getting into his accomplishments - which tie directly into the vision. This is much better. He is speaking with conviction (even deviated from the text there for a bit on the earmarks issue) and better rhythm. Also, a MUCH better background.
Boy, I think it’s a mistake for McCain to spend time taking about Gov. Palin. She had her night. Focus on your agenda, your plans, your vision.
Biggest applause line of the night so far for Palin.
Wow. This is not good. The crowd needs to stop chanting and ignore the protesters.
HOW DID THESE PEOPLE GET IN???
10:22 p.m. - The folks I’m watching with just pointed out we should start the “my friends” drinking game.
I don’t like this background at all. I’ll be honest - it does seem a little small - this whole night. One can’t help but make mental comparisons to Obama’s speech event.
Perhaps Governor Palin could take a few warning shots at the protester? Why do the networks feel the need to show them and give them credence?
Shouting down the protesters. The Left really is classless.
Why is the background bright green?
Brokaw: “He knows he can’t top Sarah Palin from last night or Barack Obama from last week.” Ugh.
A few initial observations. The podium mirrors the traditional Presidential podium. His appearing on the stage was, perhaps, a little too dramatic. I’m on NBC - Tom Brokaw and Brian Williams talk over the applause. Talking about age. Shut up. Let this moment happen.
10:12 p.m. Here comes the Mac.
MORE FRED!
Nice “sea to shining sea” imagery. “The change will come from strength from a man who found history in a tiny dank cell thousands of miles from home.” The change drinking game should start now…
You know, even though we’ve heard it before, every time I hear the fact that he was a POW for more than five years. It really is incredible - I can’t fathom how you make it through that. I really can’t. Regardless of everything else, it is a remarkable story - and a remarkable life.
Here we go with the video…
10:02 p.m.: Getting ready for John McCain’s speech. Cindy’s speech was…ok. But I was having a hard time paying attention. I wonder if Sarah Palin still steals the show, even tonight. McCain really needs to shine.